SC TO-C 1 d497209dsctoc.htm SCHEDULE TO Schedule TO

 

 

UNITED STATES

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

WASHINGTON, D.C. 20549

 

 

SCHEDULE TO

TENDER OFFER STATEMENT UNDER SECTION 14(d)(1)

OR 13(e)(1) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934

 

 

ELAN CORPORATION, PLC

(Name of Subject Company (Issuer))

RP MANAGEMENT, LLC

(Names of Filing Persons (Offeror))sec.gov

Ordinary Shares, par value €0.05 each

(Title of Class of Securities)

G29539106

(CUSIP Number of Class of Securities)

American Depositary Shares, each representing one Ordinary Share

(Title of Class of Securities)

284131208

(CUSIP Number of Class of Securities)

George Lloyd

RP Management, LLC

110 East 59th St., Suite 3300

New York, NY 10022

Telephone: (212) 882-0200

(Name, address and telephone number of person authorized

to receive notices and communications on behalf of filing persons)

With a copy to:

Jeffrey L. Kochian

Akin Gump Strauss Hauer & Feld LLP

One Bryant Park

New York, New York 10036

Telephone: (212) 872-8112

 

 

CALCULATION OF FILING FEE

 

Transaction Valuation   Amount of Filing Fee
Not Applicable*   Not Applicable*
 

 

* A filing fee is not required in connection with this filing as it relates solely to preliminary communications made before the commencement of a tender offer.

 

¨ Check the box if any part of the fee is offset as provided by Rule 0-11(a)(2) and identify the filing with which the offsetting fee was previously paid. Identify the previous filing by registration statement number, or the Form or Schedule and the date of its filing.

 

Amount Previously Paid: Not applicable    Filing Party: Not applicable
Form or Registration No.: Not applicable    Date Filed: Not applicable

 

x Check the box if the filing relates solely to preliminary communications made before the commencement of a tender offer.

Check the appropriate boxes below to designate any transactions to which the statement relates:

 

  x third-party tender offer subject to Rule 14d-1.
  ¨ issuer tender offer subject to Rule 13e-4.
  ¨ going-private transaction subject to Rule 13e-3.
  ¨ amendment to Schedule 13D under Rule 13d-2.

Check the following box if the filing is a final amendment reporting the results of the tender offer:  ¨

If applicable, check the appropriate box(es) below to designate the appropriate rule provision(s) relied upon:

 

  ¨ Rule 13e-4(i) (Cross-Border Issuer Tender Offer)
  ¨ Rule 14d-1(d) (Cross-Border Third-Party Tender Offer)

 

 

 


On March 6, 2013, RP Management, LLC made the following investor presentation available:


Royalty Pharma Presentation Regarding Elan Proposal
6 March 2013
*
*
*
*
*
*


RP Management, LLC, founded in 1996, is the investment
manager to entities investing in royalty interests in marketed and
late stage biopharmaceutical products (these entities, together
with predecessor entities, “Royalty Pharma”)
Royalty Pharma has a 17 year track record of working with
research institutions, companies, and inventors to monetize
future royalties on leading biopharmaceutical drugs
Provides capital to pharma & biotech companies to fund late-
stage clinical trials in exchange for royalty interests
Portfolio of royalty interests in 37 products
Royalty Pharma can act quickly to make a formal offer
1
About Royalty Pharma
Company Overview
Financial Strength
Product Leadership
Portfolio includes royalties on 8 of the top 20 selling pharma and
biotech
drugs
by
worldwide
sales
expected
by
2016  ,
and
on
9
products with current sales over $1bn
Leading pharmaceutical and biotech marketers
Familiarity with multiple sclerosis via Tecfidera (BG-12) interest
2012A
Revenue:
$1.39bn²
2012A
EBITDA:
$1.35bn²
Investment grade debt rating
2012A Revenue by Therapeutic Area²
(%)
Based
on
EvaluatePharma
estimates
Derived
from
unaudited
financial
results
of
Royalty
Pharma
Investments,
an
Irish
Unit
Trust,
and
affiliates
Diversified Portfolio
Royalty Pharma product portfolio is well-diversified across
biopharmaceutical products and therapeutic areas
Portfolio consists of stable and long-dated assets
1
1
2


Chronology
of
Events
2
September 2011:
Sale of Elan Drug Technologies (EDT) to Alkermes
Summer
2012:
Post-bapineuzumab
clinical
failure
and
announcement
of
spin-off
of
Prothena,
Royalty
Pharma
developed
an
interest
in
Elan
/
Tysabri
October
December
2012:
Royalty
Pharma
had
in-person
meeting
and
several
subsequent
communications
with
Elan discussing ways in which Elan and Royalty Pharma might be able to work together, including Royalty Pharma’s
interest in potentially acquiring Elan
6
February
2013:
Biogen
and
Elan
announced
restructuring
of
their
interests
in
Tysabri;
Elan
announced
its
acquisition strategy
18
February
2013:
Call
to
Elan
Chairman
requesting
an
in-person
meeting
to
discuss
the
Proposal
20
February
2013:
In-person
meeting
with
Elan
Chairman;
offer
letter
containing
the
Proposal
delivered
to
Elan
Chairman
22 February 2013:
Elan reiterates acquisition strategy, announces $1bn share buy-back program and debt
refinancing; Elan fails to disclose it received Royalty Pharma’s $11 per Share Proposal
25
February
2013:
Royalty
Pharma
announces
the
Proposal
to
acquire
Elan
for
$11
per
Share
/
ADS;
Elan
confirms
receipt
of
Proposal
and
characterizes
Proposal
as
“highly
conditional”
Informally rejected
4
March
2013:
Elan
announces
plan
to
distribute
20%
of
Tysabri
Royalty
through
dividends
Today:
Royalty
Pharma
is
meeting
Elan
shareholders
to
move
towards
a
recommended
transaction
Terms defined in Royalty Pharma’s 6-Mar-2013 Rule 2.4 announcement have the same meanings herein
1
1


3
Full value on the table
today*
Limited, easily satisfied
pre-conditions
Ready to move quickly
Summary of Royalty Pharma Proposal
Elan board is
preventing progress…
$11 in cash for each Elan Share and Elan ADS
12.5% premium to Current Enterprise Value
EV and P/E multiples well above relevant sector multiples
Elan
shareholders
have
a
clear
choice:
full
value
in
cash
today
OR
assume risk associated with Elan acquisition strategy*
Pre-conditions are limited and typical for a transaction of this nature
We expect to complete due diligence in 20 days
J.P. Morgan, BofA Merrill Lynch and Groton acting as M&A advisors
$1.1+bn of cash on hand plus “highly confident”
letter from BofA
Merrill Lynch and J.P. Morgan; banks are prepared to provide
committed financing upon completion of diligence
Board of Elan not engaging with Royalty Pharma
Elan Shareholders should urge Elan Board to grant diligence access
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion


($ in millions, except per share data)
Pre-Approach Price ¹
Proposal Price
Elan Share Price
$10.35
$11.00
Premium over Pre-Approach Price
6.3%
Fully Diluted Shares Outstanding
601.6
602.0
Market Capitalization
$6,227
$6,622
(Less): Cash & Equivalents (31-Dec-12)
(434)
(434)
(Less): Tysabri Upfront Payment from Biogen
(3,249)
(3,249)
(Less): Sale of Alkermes shares (6-Feb-13)
(170)
(170)
(Less): Value of Prothena Stake
(19)
(19)
Plus: Liabilities
210
210
Plus: Long-Term Debt (31-Dec-12)
600
600
Fully-Diluted Enterprise Value
$3,165
$3,561
Premium over Enterprise Value
12.5%
4
Premium to Enterprise Value is the most relevant metric given large cash balance*
$11 Proposal is a 12.5% Premium on Non-Cash Assets
Note:
Unless
the
context
otherwise
permits,
terms
used
here
have
same
meaning
as
Appendix
VI
of
Royalty
Pharma’s
announcement
on
6-Mar-2013
* Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion
1
Closing price on 15-Feb-2013
2
Calculation of cash and equivalents includes $2.6m in restricted cash
3
Janssen AI Funding Commitment as at 31-Dec-2012, Restructuring accruals, Accrued transaction costs, Cambridge Collaboration termination, Unfunded pension liability
Excluding net cash, the Tysabri royalty is the only meaningful asset remaining at Elan*
Net
Cash
2
3


Royalty Pharma Proposal is a Substantial Premium to
Relevant Sector Multiples
5
2015 P / E
Multiple
2015 EV /
EBITDA
Multiple
2015 EV /
Revenue
Multiple
250%
for Specialty Pharma Companies        
(91%, as adjusted)
170%
for Large Cap Biotech Companies      
(48%, as adjusted)
We’re offering a premium to the sector multiples of:
105%
for Specialty Pharma Companies
34%
for Large Cap Biotech Companies
238%
for Specialty Pharma Companies
72%
for Large Cap Biotech Companies
Note: Please refer to Royalty Pharma’s Rule 2.4 announcement on 6-Mar-2013 for additional information and the constituents of the Large Cap Biotech Companies and Spec Pharma
Companies. Multiples based on closing share prices as at 22-Feb-2013
1
If
$3bn
of
cash
($5/share)
was
distributed
and
the
RP
Proposal
price
declined
proportionately
(with
no
change
to
earnings
forecast),
P/E
would
be
16.7x,
but
then
Elan
would
have
no
cash
to
pursue
its
acquisition
strategy.
References
to
“as
adjusted”
refer
to
calculations
based
on
this
assumption
2
Median
2015E
revenue
forecast
of
$430m
as
at
22-Feb-2013
based
on
forecasts
of
brokers
referenced
in
slide
22
in
the
appendix
1
1
1
1


30.6x  at  $11.00 Proposal
If Elan distributed $3bn ($5/share) in cash, and Proposal price
adjusted
proportionately,
the
adjusted
P/E
would
be
16.7x,
but
then
Elan would have no cash to pursue its acquisition strategy
6
8.7x
6.8x
2015 Price to Earnings Multiples
Elan Trading at a Much Higher Valuation than Successful
“Roll-up”
Specialty
Pharma
Companies
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion
1
“Roll-Up”
refers to companies whose business models include significant growth through acquisitions
2
2015E
Broker
Projected
Earnings
Per
Share
as
defined
in
Royalty
Pharma’s
Rule
2.4
announcement
dated
6-Mar-2013
Without
significant
accretive
acquisitions,
applying
Valeant
and
Jazz’s
current
multiples
to
Elan
consensus 2015e EPS²
of  $0.36  results in a significantly lower share price for Elan:
-
$2.44 assuming Jazz P/E of 6.8x
-
$3.15 assuming Valeant P/E of  8.7x
Elan plans to leverage its efficient tax domicile to make acquisitions around the globe
Valeant Pharmaceuticals International, Inc and Jazz Pharmaceuticals Plc are both companies with
efficient non-US tax domiciles that are successful “roll-up”
Specialty Pharma Companies
Valeant
and
Jazz
both
trade
at
much
lower
P/E
multiples
than
Elan,
and
they
have
larger
infrastructures
that
allow
for
synergies
which
Elan
does
not
have*
1
1


7
8.7x
6.8x
Elan Will Need to Fill a Significant Gap in EPS to Warrant an $11
Share Price Based On Other Specialty Pharma Company Multiples
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion
1
2015E
Broker
Projected
Earnings
Per
Share
as
defined
in
Royalty
Pharma’s
Rule
2.4
announcement
dated
6-Mar-2013
2
$1bn
share
repurchase
at
$11/share
implies
91m
shares
repurchased
(shares
outstanding
decline
from
602m
to
511m)
bringing
2015
existing
business
EPS
to
$0.42
and
a
gap
of
~$0.95
2015 Price to Earnings (P/E) Multiples
$11 share price / Valeant’s 2015 P/E of 8.7x  =  $1.26
$11 share price / Jazz’s 2015 P/E of 6.8x       =  $1.62
2015 EPS Required to Trade at Comparable P/E Multiples With
$11 Share Price
Analysts that cover Elan estimate that its existing
business (i.e. primarily Tysabri) will generate 2015
EPS of approx. $0.36
Direct comparison to Jazz and Valeant suggests Elan
will need to acquire new businesses or products that
contribute an additional $0.90 to $1.26 in 2015 EPS
to fill the EPS gap and trade at comparable multiples
As illustrated, Elan would need to multiply its 2015
EPS by 3.5x to 4.5x over the next two years to fill its
EPS gap
Key question: can Elan turn ~$3bn in cash into
~$1.00 of incremental EPS by 2015? This would
require spending $3bn to acquire ~$600m of
incremental net income by 2015 from new businesses
(implying a purchase multiple of 5x 2015 net income).
The $1bn share repurchase would leave only ~$2bn
for acquisitions, implying that Elan would need to
acquire ~$480m of incremental net income (implying
a purchase multiple of 4.2x 2015 net income)  .
1
2


About the Tysabri Transaction
Announced to the market on 6 February 2013
Expected to close in 2Q 2013
On completion of the Tysabri Transaction, Elan will give up its 50% profit share in Tysabri in
exchange for:
$3.25bn in cash
A tiered royalty on Tysabri sales
12% on sales during first 12 months following closing of the Tysabri Transaction
After 12 months, 18% royalty on first $2bn of annual sales and 25% royalty on annual sales over $2bn
Tiered royalty structure allocates more of the lower risk cash flows (<$2bn in annual sales) to
Biogen, and makes the value allocated to Elan more dependent on higher risk cash flows (>$2bn in
annual sales)
In addition, on completion of the Tysabri Transaction:
The collaboration agreement between Biogen and Elan will terminate (eliminating change of control
provision)
Biogen will have full operational control of, and majority economic interest in, Tysabri
After the Tysabri Transaction, substantially all of Elan’s value will consist of net cash of
approximately $3.1bn and a royalty interest in Tysabri
8


On 6 February, Elan Revealed its True Colors*
9
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion
1
Royalty
Pharma
has
underscored
certain
portions
of
the
passages
for
emphasis
Use of majority of cash for
acquisitions
Unclear and unfocused acquisition
strategy*
Vague statements regarding
returning cash to shareholders*
Little concern for shareholder views*
Stock fell 10%
Our Perspective
of Key Points Made*
Quote
“As far as usage of this capital upon close, they include, but are not limited
to, therapeutic opportunities across broad therapies.  We are basically
agnostic to therapeutic focus”
. . . “we are somewhat agnostic to different
geographies
. . . they all hold some appeal, depending on what part of the
geography you’re interested in
. . .  we are not particularly interested in
large markets, large indications of primary care, but large markets in
smaller indications would be attractive and vice versa.”
“And we still do like some very specific, unique science things.”
“At the right time and in the right manner, we would intend to provide some
portion of this capital back to shareholders over time.”
“We are not going to satisfy all investors on every category . . . So anyway,
everyone can vote with their feet
. . .”
“But to emphasize, the $3.25 billion is a lot of money. There is a lot of
assets out there. Our goal as we sit here today is that the majority of that
capital over time should be put into businesses, again, in a balanced way.
But again, some portion of it, given that we brought forward the value, will
be returned to shareholders at the right time and post-close and as we
sequence it against other transactions”
1


Following Royalty Pharma Offer, Elan Changed its Tune*
10
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion
1
RBC and Deutsche Bank notes published on 4-Mar-2013
“We greatly value our shareholder relationships and the access to
equity
capital these relationships give us and we appreciate the time horizon of
many of our long term holders. We will continue to work on ways to
unlock incremental value to their direct benefit.”
"The vast majority of our investor base simply don't view Royalty's
indication as worthy of any discussion period."
“We don’t see Royalty Pharma as a credible counterparty to have any
strategic discussions with. We’re not looking for any price.”
Elan Shareholders Should View This
Change of Heart with Skepticism*
Post-Offer Announcements
22 February:
$1bn share repurchase program
Appreciation for long term shareholders
4 March:
Dividend of 20% Tysabri royalty, but
Statement of current intention only –
no long-term binding commitment
Brokers calculate a 1-2% yield
No clarity on 80% retained
Interview remarks by CEO reject any
discussions with Royalty Pharma
“We're not in any discussions with [Royalty Pharma] at all on any
topic
and we don't see any need to have those discussions."
First comments, or lack thereof, are often more revealing*
Change of heart prompted by Royalty Pharma Proposal*
Management does not appear to be focused on maximizing shareholder value*
4 March CEO interview remarks:  “We’re not looking for any price”
1


11
Following 6 February Announcement, Elan Shares Faced
Pressure, Counterbalanced by Speculation Elan Could be Acquired
*
Note: Median broker target price calculated from broker notes released after the Tysabri Transaction announcement and prior to 25-Feb-2013.  *This is not a valuation or profit forecast
1
Based
on
broker
notes
released
after
the
Tysabri
Transaction
announcement
and
prior
to
25-Feb-2013
(the
date
of
release
of
Royalty
Pharma’s
initial
Rule
2.4
announcement)
2
For
brokers
with
Euro-denominated
target
prices,
change
in
target
price
is
on
a
constant
currency
basis
(i.e.
excludes
impact
of
changes
in
USD:EUR
exchange
rate)
3
Report
includes
at
least
some
commentary
on
these
issues
9
out
of
11
analysts
have
price
targets
at
or
below
Royalty
Pharma’s
Proposal
price
1


Significant Execution Risk Associated with Elan’s New Strategy*
12
Royalty Pharma believes that:
Attractive strategic assets in the pharmaceutical industry are in short supply
There is strong competition for such assets from many large buyers with real operating synergies . . .
. . . driving high prices that make the creation of value through acquisitions difficult
There is no certainty that Elan will be able to deploy capital in ways that create value
Current senior management of Elan has not made significant acquisitions or in-licenses of
late-stage products at Elan; does not have a proven acquisition / in-licensing track record*
Known instead for divestiture of bapineuzumab, Elan Drug Technologies, Prothena and Tysabri
A successful acquisition strategy would typically require Elan to build a costly operating
infrastructure and sales force in order to allow it to realize synergies from acquisitions*
Investments
typically
required
in
connection
with
acquisitions
/
in-licenses
could
dilute
Elan’s
net
income
and
cash
flow
for
some
period,
and
perhaps
even
cause
those
to
become
negative
Each new investment will likely be scrutinized by Elan shareholders and analysts for near
term value creation potential, increasing volatility in Elan shares*
Proposal
allows
investors
to
redeploy
the
cash
themselves
rather
than
have
Elan
acquire
equivalent assets on their behalf and pay a control premium
Shareholders will have limited control over what Elan does with its cash
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion


Value of Tysabri Economics Retained by Elan ($ bn)
Illustrative % of  Elan’s Tysabri economics sold to Biogen for cash
46%
48%
50%
52%
54%
Illustrative % of Elan’s Tysabri economics retained by Elan in
the form of Tysabri royalty
54%
52%
50%
48%
46%
Purchase price paid by Biogen for Tysabri economics acquired
$3.25
$3.25
$3.25
$3.25
$3.25
Implied residual value of Elan’s Tysabri Royalty
$3.81
$3.52
$3.25
$3.00
$2.77
Proposal Enterprise Value
$3.56
$3.56
$3.56
$3.56
$3.56
Royalty
Pharma
Proposal
Premium
-6.6%
1.2%
9.6%
18.7%
28.7%
Tysabri Transaction set a real benchmark for (a) the value of the Tysabri Royalty retained by Elan,¹
and (b) the price of an
arms-length transaction at which Elan was a willing seller*
Synergies
realizable
by
Biogen
(~$30m
annual
operating
synergies  )
reduce
the
net
cost
to
Biogen,
suggesting
the
Proposal
is
even
more competitive relative to Biogen’s net effective price*
No other buyer besides Biogen can realize such synergies; no further synergies available
Proposal is at a Premium to Price Paid by Biogen in Tysabri
Transaction*
13
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion
1
Percentage retained by Elan not disclosed by either Biogen or Elan. Percentage can be approximated by dividing, on a year-by-year basis, the estimated Tysabri royalty to Elan by
50% of Tysabri stand-alone operating profit
2
Biogen 6-Feb-2013 presentation
3
Assumes minimal value ascribed to other assets as described on slide 14
2
3


Royalty Pharma Proposal Reflects Full Value for All Elan Assets*
14
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion
Note:
Per
share
values
calculated
based
on
fully
diluted
shares
of
602.0m
at
$11
per
share
Proposal
price
as
set
out
in
Appendix
VI
of
Royalty
Pharma’s
announcement
on
6-Mar-2013
1
Pro forma for the completion of the Tysabri Transaction (net cash adjusted for $3.25bn upfront proceeds from Biogen); includes impact of $123m outstanding bapi commitment
2
$123m remaining commitment disclosed in Elan 20-F for year ended 31-Dec-2012; $60-80m expected this year with $30m already paid in Jan-2013
Value
Comment
Hard Assets:
Net Cash¹
$3.1bn ($5.1/share)
Not sensible to pay a premium  for cash*
Tysabri Royalty
$3.25bn is mid-point of range,
excluding synergies, ignoring
increased risk of tiered royalty
(See slide 13) ($5.4/share)*
Not sensible to pay a premium for a financial asset like a royalty: should be
valued on the basis of financial metrics (i.e. intrinsic value)*
Biogen
now
has
full
operating
control
little
or
no
strategic
value
at
Elan*
Substantial portion of cash flow and value derived post 2020 patent expiry*
Financial Attributes:
NOLs
Less than $187.5m
($0.3/share)
Maximum value of $187.5m (= $1.5bn in putative NOLs times 12.5% Irish
tax rate) provided Elan can use all NOLs upfront
If they are used over time, net present value of NOLs is less than $187.5m
Irish Tax Domicile
Difficult to value; perhaps no
value if no suitor with need for
domicile comes forward
Does not differentiate Elan from many other pharma companies in low-tax
jurisdictions (e.g Jazz, Valeant)*
Extremely difficult now to use Irish domicile to lower tax rate of non-Irish
businesses as a result of change in law following Alkermes/EDT deal
Offsets:
Operating Expenses
incl. ELND005
$170-190m in 2013
(-$0.3/share) annually
These expenses would decrease cash available to Elan Shareholders;
ELND005 clinical trial costs not disclosed
Expenses assoc. with
bapineuzumab (bapi)
$60-80m remaining in 2013 for
bapi
; no visible value in
excess of investment required*
$123m commitment remains for bapi
Other Considerations:
Business Development
Value destruction a real
possibility*
Scarcity of assets, competition, lack of synergies and lack of management
track record imply significant execution risk*
2
2


Limited, Customary Pre-Conditions to a Firm Offer
Satisfactory completion of customary due diligence (including management meetings)
Completion of Tysabri Transaction
Other customary conditions as set out in Rule 2.4 announcement of 25 February 2013
15
Our Proposal has only limited and customary pre-conditions…
…All can be satisfied quickly; we expect to complete due diligence in 20 days


Reasons Why Royalty Pharma’s Proposal is Compelling
16
1.
Allows
Elan
Shareholders
to
immediately
receive
full
value
for
their
Shares
in
cash*
2.
Proposal is at a premium to price paid by Biogen in Tysabri Transaction*
3.
Proposal
represents
a
cash
premium
of
12.5%
to
the
Current
Enterprise
Value,
and
EV
and
P/E multiples well above relevant sector multiples
4.
Significant execution risk associated with Elan’s new strategy*
5.
Elan’s senior management lacks a successful acquisition / in-licensing track record at Elan*
6.
Post-Tysabri Transaction, Elan has little or no strategic value; the field of likely acquirors has
narrowed sharply*
7.
Royalty
Pharma
is
ready
and
able
to
move
quickly
to
announcement
of
a
formal
offer
once
given appropriate due diligence access
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion


The Choice for Elan Shareholders is Clear
17
Cash Out Now at Full Value
Trust That Elan’s Acquisition Strategy
Will Succeed
Elan
Shareholders
may
never
get
another
opportunity
to
make
this
choice
and
should
urge the Elan Board to engage with Royalty Pharma*
Receive full value for Elan shares in cash
now*
Certainty of value
Remain invested in a company with two
material assets:
A royalty interest in Tysabri
Cash, the majority of which management has
stated will be used for acquisitions
Accept the execution risk associated with
Elan’s acquisition strategy
OR
*  Denotes a Royalty Pharma opinion


Appendix
18


Royalty Pharma Has a Strong Track Record Raising Capital
In the Debt and Equity Markets
19


From
To
TYSABRI intellectual
property and know-how
shared within collaboration
100% of Intellectual
Property and know-how
owned by Biogen Idec
50:50 TYSABRI profit split
All of TYSABRI sales,
operating expense and
profit to Biogen Idec
Upfront
payment
to
Elan
Sales-based contingent
payments to Elan
50:50 TYSABRI decision
rights via multiple joint
committees
100 % controlled by Biogen
Idec
Day-to day operating
activity mostly Biogen Idec
100% operated by Biogen
Idec
Eliminates change of
control provision
Biogen Gained Full Strategic Control of Tysabri
Below –
in Biogen’s Own Words –
are the Key Elements of the Transaction
Synergies from consolidating collaboration
Will range from $20M to $35M annually
“Asset purchase”
a very appealing structure
Known asset
Simple and seamless transaction
Allows for capturing tax-related benefits
Tax-related benefits specific to asset purchase
structure
Purchase price amortization benefit will range from
$40M to $50M annually. This will apply only on a
GAAP basis
Increase in Manufacturing Deduction benefit
Current plan to cost share a late-stage asset
Sales-based contingent payments also tax
deductible
Use of offshore cash
Majority of upfront funded from ex-U.S. cash
Immediately and sustainably accretive to
earnings
20
From Collaboration to Asset Ownership
Attractive Operational and Financial Benefits
Source: Biogen 6-Feb-2013 presentation. Capitalized terms used in this slide are those used in that Biogen presentation


Highly Volatile Performance Over the Last 10 Years With a
Number of Surprises to the Downside
21
Note: BTK is the NYSE AMEX Biotechnology Index, NBI is the NASDAQ Biotechnology Index 


Sources and Bases
22
Slide
1:
Royalty
Pharma
company
documents
and
unaudited
results
for
the
financial
year
ended
31-Dec-2012;
EvaluatePharma
estimates
for
2016
Slide 2: Elan company filings and press releases; Biogen press release 6-Feb-2013
Slide 3: Current Enterprise Value calculation in Appendix VI of Royalty Pharma’s Rule 2.4 announcement dated 6-Mar-2013
Slide 4: Current Enterprise Value and Proposal Enterprise Value calculations in Appendix VI of Royalty Pharma’s Rule 2.4 announcement dated 6-Mar-2013
Slide 5: see Royalty Pharma’s Rule 2.4 announcement dated 6-Mar-2013 for further details on the basis of calculation of Elan’s 2015 Broker Projected Earnings Per
Share multiple and 2015 Broker Projected EBITDA multiple; calculation of Large Cap Biotech Companies and Spec Pharma Companies multiples based on I/B/E/S
consensus as downloaded from FactSet on 22-Feb-2013 (for forecasts), FactSet on 22-Feb-2013 (for share price data and numbers of shares outstanding) and
company filings (for balance sheet data); Elan median 2015E revenue forecast based on forecasts made by Berenberg, Cowen, Davy, Deutsche Bank, Morgan
Stanley, RBC Capital Markets and UBS
Slide 6: Valeant and Jazz multiples based on I/B/E/S consensus as downloaded from FactSet on 22-Feb-2013 (for forecasts), FactSet on 22-Feb-2013 (for share price
data and numbers of shares outstanding) and company filings (for
balance sheet data). See Royalty Pharma’s Rule 2.4 announcement dated 6-Mar-2013 for further
details on the basis of calculation of Elan’s 2015 Broker Projected Earnings Per Share multiple
Slide
7:
2015E
Broker
Projected
Earnings
Per
Share
as
defined
in
Royalty
Pharma’s
Rule
2.4
announcement
dated
6-Mar-2013;
Valeant
and
Jazz
multiples
sourced
as described above
Slide 8: Elan and Biogen press releases dated 6-Feb-2013; net cash calculation in Appendix VI of Royalty Pharma’s Rule 2.4 announcement dated 6-Mar-2013
Slide 9: Elan press release dated 6-Feb-2013; CallStreet transcript of Elan conference call 6-Feb-2013; FactSet
Slide 10: Broker research; Elan press releases dated 22-Feb-2013 and 4-Mar-2013; Bloomberg article dated 4-Mar-2013; Reuters article published 4-Mar-2013
Slide 11: Broker research; Bloomberg as at 23-Feb-2013
Slide 13: Royalty Pharma analysis based on disclosed terms of Tysabri Transaction from Elan and Biogen press releases dated 6-Feb-2013 and Biogen investor
presentation dated 6-Feb-2013
Slide 14: Net cash calculated in Appendix VI of Royalty Pharma’s Rule 2.4 announcement dated 6-Mar-2013; US$1.5bn of NOLs and expenses associated with bapi
referenced in CallStreet transcript of Elan conference call on 6-Feb-2013; operating expenses based on disclosure in Elan's announcement of its results for the 2012
financial year made on February 6, 2013; Elan 20-F for year ended 31-Dec-2012
Slide 16: Royalty Pharma’s Rule 2.4 announcement dated 6-Mar-2013
Slide 19: Royalty Pharma company documents and press releases
Slide 20: Biogen 6-Feb-2013 presentation
Slide 21: FactSet as at 22-Feb-2013; Elan company filings and press releases


23
Additional
Information
This document does not constitute an offer to buy or the solicitation of an offer to sell any securities. This document relates to a potential business combination transaction with Elan proposed by
Royalty Pharma and is not a substitute for any tender offer statement or any other document in the event that Royalty Pharma files such a document with the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission (the “SEC”) in connection with the proposed transaction. INVESTORS AND SECURITY HOLDERS ARE URGED TO READ ANY SUCH DOCUMENTS FILED WITH THE SEC
CAREFULLY
IN
THEIR
ENTIRETY
IF
AND
WHEN
THEY
BECOME
AVAILABLE
BECAUSE
THEY
WILL
CONTAIN
IMPORTANT
INFORMATION
ABOUT
THE
PROPOSED
TRANSACTION.
Any
such
documents
will
be
available
free
of
charge
through
the
website
maintained
by
the
SEC
at
www.sec.gov
or
by
directing
a
request
to
the
persons
listed
above.
Forward
Looking
Statements
This document may include certain "forward looking statements" with respect to the business, strategy and plans of Elan and Royalty Pharma and their respective expectations relating to the
Possible Offer and their future financial condition and performance. Statements that are not historical facts, including statements about Elan or Royalty Pharma or their respective management’s
beliefs and expectations, are forward looking statements. Words such as "believes", "anticipates", "estimates", "expects", "intends", "aims", "potential", "will", "would", "could", "considered", "likely",
and variations of these words and similar future or conditional expressions are intended to identify forward looking statements but are not the exclusive means of identifying such statements. By
their nature, forward looking statements involve risk and uncertainty because they relate to events and depend upon future circumstances that may or may not occur.
Examples
of
such
forward
looking
statements
include,
but
are
not
limited
to,
statements
about
expected
benefits
and
risks
associated
with
the
Possible
Offer;
projections
or
expectations
of
profit
attributable to shareholders; anticipated provisions or write-downs, economic profit, dividends, capital structure or any other financial items or ratios; statements of plans, objectives or goals of
Elan,
Royalty
Pharma
or
the
combined
company
following
the
Possible
Offer;
statements
about
the
future
trends
in
interest
rates,
liquidity,
foreign
exchange
rates,
stock
market
levels
and
demographic
trends
and
any
impact
that
those
matters
may
have
on
Elan,
Royalty
Pharma
or
the
combined
company
following
the
Possible
Offer;
statements
concerning
any
future
Irish,
U.S.
or
other economic environment or performance; statements about strategic goals, competition, regulation, regulatory approvals, dispositions and consolidation or technological developments in the
financial services industry; and statements of assumptions underlying such statements.
Forward looking statements only speak as of the date on which they are made, and the events discussed in this document may not occur. Subject to compliance with applicable law and
regulation,
Royalty
Pharma
is
not
under
any
obligation
to
update
publicly
or
revise
forward
looking
statements,
whether
as
a
result
of
new
information,
future
events
or
otherwise.
Rule
8.3
Disclosure
statement
Any
holder
of
1%
or
more
of
any
class
of
relevant
securities
of
Elan
Corporation
plc
may
have
disclosure
obligations
under
Rule
8.3
of
the
Irish
Takeover
Rules.
Responsibility
Statement
The member of RP Management, LLC accepts responsibility for the information contained in this document, save that the only responsibility accepted by the member of RP Management, LLC in
respect of the information in this document relating to Elan, the Elan Group, the Board of Elan and the persons connected with them, which has been compiled from published sources, has been to
ensure that such information has been correctly and fairly reproduced or presented (and no steps have been taken by the member of RP Management, LLC to verify this information).  To the best
of the knowledge and belief of the member of RP Management, LLC (having taken all reasonable care to ensure that such is the case), the information contained in this document for which he
accepts responsibility is in accordance with the facts and does not omit anything likely to affect the import of such information.
No
Profit
Forecast
No
statement
in
this
document
shall
constitute
a
profit
forecast
for
any
period,
nor
should
any
statement
be
interpreted
to
mean
that
earnings
or
earnings
per
sharewill
necessarily
be
greater
or
lesser than those for the relevant preceding financial periods for either Royalty Pharma or Elan as appropriate.
No
Asset
Valuations
No statement in this document shall constitute an asset valuation.
Capitalized
terms
All capitalized terms in this document shall have the same meaning as set forth in the Royalty Pharma Announcement of 6 March 2013, unless the context otherwise requires or unless otherwise
specified.